Saturday, June 7, 2014

The Nutrition Debate #216: Is Low-Carb High-Protein or High-Fat?


The cognoscenti (my regular readers, who are “in-the-know”) know that the answer to this question is high-fat. But I squirm in my seat when I hear someone who appears to be informed on the subject of low-carb dieting say, “it is high-protein.”

That happened again last night while I was watching – reveling  really – in a discussion on one of my favorite TV shows in which the subject of an entire segment was the recent Wall Street Journal “Saturday Essay,” titled, “The Questionable Link Between Saturated Fat and Heart Disease.” This person accurately blamed the obesity epidemic on the American (or Western) diet which is very high in carbs and processed foods; but then he proceeded instead to advocate for a diet high in protein! That is WRONG, WRONG, WRONG!

Of course, I shouldn’t complain about the “back side” of the message being garbled. The “front side” was right: diets that are very high in carbohydrates and processed foods ARE the reason we as a civilization for 50 years have been getting fatter and fatter.  And the Wall Street Journal article got it right. Had the person who “appears to be informed” done his homework (read the WSJ article), he would have known that. If you haven’t you should read the Journal piece now. They also correctly noted that the beginning of this very large, population-wide, public health “experiment” in eating “low-fat” can be attributed to Ancel Keys. Gary Taubes (#5 here) brought him to my attention, and I first wrote about Keys here (#3).

Keys was an American physiologist whose “Six Nation” and later “Seven Country Study” was just bad science and, incredibly, became dietary dogma when it was first published. Keys made the cover of Time Magazine in 1961 and joined the board of the American Heart Association. This was just a few years after President Eisenhower had had his heart attack and went on the Pritikin diet. Keys’s studies, which were later revealed to be “cherry picked,” focused on the Mediterranean Diet. He reported the use of very little red meat (there isn’t much red meat to eat there anyway) but the sampling was done during Lent in a Catholic country!

Anyway, a low-carb diet, which is the antidote to the fattening low-fat diet (you read that right), is high fat and not high-protein. Let’s talk numbers (percentages) for a few minutes. Diets can be classified in what are called Macronutrient Ratios:

The Low Fat Diet: The Standard American Diet (SAD, for short!) is high carb, moderate fat and low protein. The FDA’s Nutrition Panel on processed foods, based on a 2,000 calorie a day diet, is comprised of 60% calories from carbs, 30% fat and 10% protein. The dietary Dictocrats have moved slightly away from that formulation in recent years, advocating as low as 40% to 50% carbs, but steadfastly maintaining at the same time a target of less than 30% fat. That can only mean an increase in protein. To the extent carbs are reduced (from 60%) and fats do not exceed 30% (and a lower percentage is advocated by the FDA), only protein can rise. Remember, there are only three macronutrients: carbs, fat and protein. Something’s gotta give.

Another thing: To the extent that the Vegan lobby has stealthily exercised its stranglehold on the government‘s dietary bureaucracy, a plant-based diet is increasingly being advocated. Plants are carbohydrates. Most protein (not all, there are some proteins in legumes and nuts) is animal-based. So, the struggle to maintain a high-carb, low-protein macronutrient ratio goes on within the establishment. It will be interesting to see the 2015 Nutritional Guidelines for Americans.

The Low Carb Diet: The macronutrient ratios for a low-carb diet are all over the place. This is okay with me since making a transition from 60% carb to 40 to 50% to say 20% is a very good thing – but it takes time and a lot of effort. Besides, there is no “official” percentage for a low-carb diet. So, let’s say for our purposes that a standard low-carb diet is 20% carb, 20% protein and 60% fat. That’s really scary to some people, especially when there is so much confusion about “good” fats. That’s why the WSJ article caused such a stir. (Google “the nutrition debate good fats” for some of my columns on fat.) But there is another mitigating factor: All these percentages are in calories, and since fat has more than twice as many calories per gram as both protein and carbohydrates (9 vs. 4), you really are eating less than half as much fat as you think.

Very Low Carb: When I first started low carb dieting, it was on Atkins Induction, which is actually Very Low Carb: My ratios (not Atkins’s) were 10% carb, 30% protein and 60% fat. I later tweaked that to 7% carb, 25% protein and 68% fat. Today, I aspire to eat 5% carb, 20% protein and 75% fat (by calorie, remember). Of course, you don’t eat percentages of food; you eat grams, which are actually a measure of weight of the macronutrient content of a particular food, not the weight of the food itself. These quantities are determined by software that some of the compulsive among us (including me) have used.

So, low-carb is really moderate protein and high fat. The lower the carb percentage, the higher the fat. Some call it LCHF. Google The Diet Doctor (Andreas, Eenfeldt, MD) if you want to learn more about LCHF.

What does your eating plan look like?

Friday, June 6, 2014

The Nutrition Debate #215: Just Google “The Nutrition Debate”


 
I’ve been writing this column, and blogging twice a week at thenutritiondebate.com, for several years. Blogger, the platform that I use, has a “follower” function, but it no longer works in Internet Explorer (Google wants me to switch to Chrome). Many of my regular readers follow me by RSS feed, available at the top of the blog in the Blogger format, but most of my new readers are introduced to “The Nutrition Debate” by Google searches on topics of interest to them, and that’s fine.

Blogger provides me with some simple statistics or my readership by day, week, month and all-time. It also tracks my audience by country, traffic source, and post (column), so I have a broad idea of who, how and what my readership is. More than half of my readers are in the U. S. Other countries where I am widely read include the UK, Canada, Germany and France. Recently I had over 1,000 page views in a 1-hour period from Israel. (I’d love to know how that happened and what the Israelis found so interesting. So if somebody knows, please leave a comment or send me an email.)

I also have a loyal following in Sweden, Russia, Hong Kong and Singapore. The Singapore readership in on a site where a very popular and avuncular social network leader writes on the subject of “Clean Eating.” He provides occasional links to my columns and has even posted a few as permanent resources for his multitude of followers.

It also appears that someone in both China and Ukraine has “hijacked” my content (with or without attribution, who knows?) and appears to post everything I write. They may use Google Translate to post them in Chinese and Russian – again, who knows? I just know that in the last year I have been getting many thousands of page views from China and Ukraine. If somebody there can tell me how that is happening, I’d like to know. I don’t object, mind you. I write this column for educational purposes and have no pecuniary interest in it. There is no revenue, and I have no interest in ever commercializing it.

This might also be a good time to mention that I have a wonderful and intrepid “volunteer editor,” a person who makes my writing clearer, checks my facts, and whose digital resources are almost as vast as Google’s (slight exaggeration there). Her acumen in all things health and nutrition is only exceeded by her generous heart and her interest in spreading the word about good nutrition and healthy eating.

So, as Google seems to be the main, continuing source of new readers, I encourage this method of using that search engine. Just as Google has a “feeling lucky” search function, you could do the same. Just type “The Nutrition Debate” in the “window,” hit “enter,” and let ‘er rip. I guarantee that my blog will come up first and perhaps again on the first page as well. Who knows what Google will find for you that may be of interest? Google’s selects. You choose.

Of course, if you want to do a more targeted search, you could do something more “advanced.” Enter “The Nutrition Debate” and then another word or phrase of interest to you. Let Google do the work. To see how well this works, I just entered “the nutrition debate triglycerides” and all ten (10) Google results were columns that I have written on triglycerides. This works very well in the absence of “tags,” “labels,” or “key words.” Who needs an alphabetical Index or even a Table of Contents?

On the other hand, if you’d like to see a list of all my columns, in some browsers you can see a list in the order written at the top right corner of the homepage, listed first under “Favorite Links and Videos.” Alas, this no longer works in IE either.

So, if you are one of those who increasingly rely on Google (or another search engine), as I do, I encourage you to try the advanced search technique described above. I am too lazy, and too much of a Luddite, at this point, to go back over 214 columns and enter tags, labels and key words. Use technology to search instead. It works for me. Just Google “the nutrition debate” and another key word or phrase, press “enter,” and “get lucky.”

Then, if you like what you have read, go to the RSS feed and get my blog delivered twice a week to your hand-held device, tablet, laptop, or work station. And by all means, send me your comments and ideas. I’m always looking for subjects of interest to both me and my readers.

Saturday, May 31, 2014

The Nutrition Debate #214: How I Lost 125 Pounds (Part 2)

The Nutrition Debate #214: How I Lost 125 Pounds (Part 2)
In the last column I told how I determined how much carbohydrate and protein I should eat for weight loss, blood sugar control, vastly improved blood pressure, blood lipids, inflammation markers and overall better health. You (and your doctor) would be very happy to have these results (as I and mine are), but the story doesn’t end there. There is more to tell.
I lost 60 pounds on Atkins Induction in just nine months (1½ pounds a week) by just writing down everything I ate every day and estimating carbohydrate grams. No measuring – just guessing. It gave me heightened awareness and accountability for what I decided to eat – and I learned a lot about which foods contained carbs and how they affected my blood sugar. When I started to eat Very Low Carb (VLC) in 2002, I had been a type 2 diabetic for 16 years, and up to then in complete denial. I left my health care, and my diabetes care in particular, to my doctor. Now, I rely on self-care for my diabetes health.
After 4 years of trying to stay on Atkins Induction (20g of carbohydrate a day), I started to slip and I gained 12 pounds. I then switched to Dr. Richard K. Bernstein’s program (30g carbs/day) for diabetics. I wanted to lose that 12 pounds again and a lot more. That’s when I decided to count the protein I ate too and to keep a more detailed record of what I ate. After researching the protein question, I devised my own method for determining when and how much protein to eat, which I explained in #213. I started out at 90 grams of protein a day. That only left fat and total calories, to decide, and I chose an online site to do all of the calculations. All I had to do was to remember everything I ate and enter the estimated quantities. The software did all the rest.
I determined how many grams of fat to eat a day by backing into the calculation. I wanted to lose 2 pounds a week. At 3500 calories/pound that is 7000 calories/week, or 1000 calories/day. If a mostly sedentary, older male who doesn’t exercise needs 2200 calories/day to maintain his weight, then I would need to eat just 1200 calories/day to lose 2 pounds a week. And 90 grams of protein + 30 grams of carbohydrate = 120 grams, times 4 calories/gram, equals 480 calories. Subtracted from 1200, that leaves 720 calories for fat. At 9 calories/gram for fat, that means my allowance for fat was 80 grams a day.
That’s where I started on Bernstein. I didn’t care about macronutrient ratios or ketosis. I just ate VLC and what I thought was moderate protein. I lost 100 pounds in 50 weeks (2 pounds a week, as planned) starting with this regimen and lowering my protein amount as I went along. I lowered protein from 90 grams to 75 and then to 65 grams a day. Today, I strive to eat just 60 grams of protein a day, which is still 20% above the Nutrition Facts panel guidelines.
Later I became interested in macronutrient ratios. The diet that worked for me (where I lost 100 pounds) was 10% carbs (30g/day), 30% protein (90g/day) and 60% fat (80g/day). Thirty percent protein is the highest most experts recommend for protein, and then only if you have no kidney problems. Your blood markers for kidney disease should be tested by your doctor before you start and rechecked annually thereafter on any moderate or moderately high protein diet.
As I lost weight, and discovered low carb foods that I liked for breakfast and lunch, and new good fats, and small low carb/protein suppers, I lowered both my protein and carbs, and increased my fat percentages. My macronutrient ratios changed, from 7% carb (20g), 25% (75g) protein and 68% fat (90g) to 5% carb (15g), 25% protein (75g) and 70% fat (90g). At present they are 5% carb (15g), 20% protein (60g) and 75% fat (98g). All of these ratios are for 1200 calories a day.  
To sum up, when I eat according to my plan, my body is happy, and I am burning two pounds of body fat a week. It’s pretty easy to do so long as “my body,” which I have come to think of as a separate entity that I am living in, is “happy.” And it is telling me that it is. I just eat small meals at mealtime. This is called non-homeostatic eating. That is, I am not eating because my body is telling me to. I am not hungry at mealtimes. I am eating because breakfast, lunch and supper (I no longer call it “dinner”) are, in our culture, mealtimes. My body decides what to do with it, to maintain muscle and burn fat.
So, what do I eat? Breakfast is 3 eggs, 1 strip of bacon and a cup of coffee with stevia powder and a little half and half. Lunch is usually a can of sardines (in olive oil!). I drink the oil. And supper is a small portion of protein, usually a fattymeat or fish, and a low-carb vegetable, either tossed in butter or roasted in olive oil. If I snack before dinner, my favorite is radish slices with salt and a dollop of butter or ghee. Sometimes I have a small (measured) portion of nuts. Macadamia nuts have the fewest Omega 6s, while hazelnuts, almonds or pecans have only moderate amounts. Pistachios and cashews are too high in carbs and walnutsmuch too high in Omega 6s. Of course, this also means I will have to have less fat with my supper.
Everything discussed in these 2 columns is addressed in more detail in the preceding 212 columns. Why not have a look?

Wednesday, May 28, 2014

The Nutrition Debate #213: How I lost 125 pounds (Part 1)

I started eating Very Low Carb (VLC) on Atkins Induction, at my doctor’s suggestion, to lose weight. I am a long-time (28yr) type 2 diabetic so after 4 years I switched to Dr. Bernstein’s program. I have been very successful at both,getting “normal” fasting blood sugars ( 80s and 90s mg/dl) on only 500mg ofMetformin once a day and losing ,at one point, 170 pounds.
When I began VLC 12 years ago, I was “maxed out” on two classes of oral meds and starting a third. Within a day of starting Atkins Induction, I was getting hypos (BG readings in the 50s and even 40s). I ate some sugar and called my doctor. He told me to cut my oral diabetes meds several times over the next few days. As I lost weight, my blood pressure gradually dropped from 130/90 to110/70 at the same level of meds. Over a period of time my HDL doubled and my triglycerides dropped by two-thirds. My Hb A1cs are now consistently in the mid to high 5s, and both my HDL/TG ratio and my hs C-Reactive Protein are almost always under 1.0. I am never hungry. I have lots of energy, and I feel great. By all these measures I am much healthier today than I was 12 years ago. How did this come about? In gradual steps, except the medication reductions came immediately.
When I first started eating VLC, for a few years I wrote down everything I atebut only counted estimated carbs. I didn’t measure anything. I just listed everything I ate and guessed at the carb content. I did this in an Excel table I created that totaled the daily estimated grams of carbohydrates. The math was simple and the method not very accurate, but I was learning about low carb eating. Since I was doing blood glucose measurements before and two hours after each meal (6 pricks/day), I was learning what foods raised my blood sugar and what foods didn’t. Ala Bernstein, I was “eating-to-the-meter.” This is a learning process every diabetic or prediabetic eating low carb for blood sugar control must do.
Then I became interested in how much protein I should eat. I didn’t care for Bernstein’s method of protein measurement. But I did subscribe to his “prescription” to eat a similarly sized, small-to-medium portion of protein with each meal, and to space the meals at regular intervals. He also counseled that, to lose weight you should reduce the portion size of protein for one meal and if that wasn’t enough, a second meal each day. This advice would later guide me to the low side on protein.
Another factor I considered is that about half of every gram or ounce of protein you eat is going to become glucose in your blood. This occurs after the protein is digested into amino acids and, if not taken up by your muscles, etc., is stored in the liver. There, through a process called gluconeogenesis, it is converted to glucose when the body calls for glucose. That is the main mechanism of the drugMetformin: to suppress the up-regulated synthesis of glucose by the liver in the disregulated sugar-based metabolism that many people have developed on the carbohydrate-based Western diet most of us eat today.
How much protein you should eat is dependent on several factors: among them age, gender, and especially level of activity. If you are very active, i.e. you exercise regularly, you will need more protein to repair and maintain the muscle tissue you have developed and use. I don’t exercise at all (except in my daily activities such as kayaking or gardening). I don’t like to sweat and besides, aren’t we advised to exercise to “work up an appetite”? If you’re trying to lose weight, as I am, who wants to do that! So, I began a search to find out how much proteinthe “experts” said I should eat.
The Nutrition Facts panel required on processed food packaging by the U. S. Government (HHS/FDA) calls for a Minimum Daily Allowance of 50 grams of protein a day. That’s 200 calories of a 2,000 calorie diet or 10%. But which is operative: 50g or 10%? If you eat less than 2,000kcal/day, say just 1,000, that would then be 20% of 1,000, wouldn’t it? More on this later.
An abstract of an authoritative paper I read said that American men eat about 16% protein by calorie and American women 15%. But the measure used by virtually everyone today is expressed in terms of grams of protein per kg of “leanbody weight” (or grams per pound in U.S. measure). This was confounding to me for two reasons: 1) The range of recommendations was so wide, and 2) the definition of “lean body weight” was imprecise, indeterminate and frequently subject to misinterpretation. This latter point is particularly true for the overweight, obese and morbidly obese, like me.  
The “experts” recommend a very wide range of protein amounts. You need to pick one and go with it. I did from the get go. For me (old, male, diabetic, morbidly obese, relatively inactive and without excessive musculature to maintain), I chose 0.6g of protein/lb of ‘lean body weight’ (about 1.3g/kg). The amount is independent of fat weight, since protein builds and maintains muscle and does other things not fat related. The BMI table says that at 5’-11” my “Normal” weight should be 150 pounds. At 0.6g of protein per pound of lean body weight, that’s 90 grams of protein a day. So, that’s where I started.

Saturday, May 24, 2014

The Nutrition Debate #212: “Everything I (ch)eat turns to fat.”

The Nutrition Debate #212: “Everything I (ch)eat turns to fat.”
“Once you develop diabetes, your metabolism is deeply committed to converting as many calories as it can into fat.”
We’ve all heard this sentiment expressed, or felt this depressing thought,numerous times, but I was especially affected recently when I read this quote on page 241 of Cate Shanahan’s Deep Nutrition. I urge you to read the book, or at least my review in #205 here and her deeply troubling observations about the medical “business” that I commented on in #206 here.
Shanahan’s book has hundreds of references, so I lament that this generalization is not sourced. I suppose it should be understood as a summation of the very well sourced material presented in her book. In any case, the quote can be read as the expression of exasperation that we, overweight and obese type 2 diabetics, feel as we continuously try to lose weight. I increasingly suspect that the undiagnosed as well as diagnosed pre-diabetics among us feel the same way. It does seem that everything we eat turns to fat, and it is damnably difficult to lose that fat.
As my readers know, I am always interested (from self-interest as well as for educational purposes) in understanding the mechanism behind our complex metabolic environment, or milieu intérieur as Claude Bernard, the 19th centuryFrench physiologist, first described homeostasis. And I think I have gained some insights into why it is that “everything I (ch)eat turns to fat” and why people with impaired glucose tolerance (IGT) and impaired fasting glucose (IFG), the medical terms for incipient type 2 diabetes, gain weight easily and lose weightwith difficulty.
In lay terms, both IGT and IFG are the equivalent of “carbohydrate intolerance,” described in The Nutrition Debate #84, “Carbohydrate Intolerance -- the new 'buzz' words.” They are the outward manifestation of a metabolic change called Insulin Resistance (IR), described in more detail in The Nutrition Debate #99, “Natural History of Type 2 Diabetes.”
The bottom line: as our bodies transition from a normal metabolism to a dysfunctional metabolism, very commonly accompanied by weight gain as an effect of this dysfunction, not a cause, our bodies undergo several  physiological changes. These changes detailed in laboratory reports and can be summed up by your waist/hip ratio. The most frequently tested are fasting glucose, hemoglobinA1c (HgA1c), the lipid panel (Total Cholesterol, LDL, HDL, and TC/HDL ratio) and triglycerides. Sometimes, when these markers are “out of sync,” a diagnosis of Metabolic Syndrome is made. All too often, the doctor just prescribes a statin and tells the patient to “exercise and eat a low-fat diet to lose weight.”
What’s missing in this “prescription”? Among other things, a test for fasting insulin. I’ll get into the specifics of this test in another column, but for now I want to explain how and why I have come to this conclusion. When I have been very good – that is, when I not only talked the talk but walked the walk, every day in every way – my fasting blood sugars have consistently been in the 80s and 90s. I can point to weeks, even months, of never or very rarely having a FBG over 100. And since it is an elevated blood glucose that causes the pancreas to produce insulin, to transport glucose in the blood to destination cells, a slightlyelevated blood glucose is associated with a slightly elevated serum insulin level.
As my readers know, and as anyone who has read Taubes’ Good Calories-Bad Calories (The Diet Delusion in the UK), or his more approachable Why We Get Fat, elevated serum insulin causes fat storage and prevents fat breakdown for energy. My column #5, about GC-BC, presents Taubes’s summation (“10 Certain Conclusions”) from his Epilogue (pg 453-454). It is a very succinct and compelling explanation of the functional role of insulin in homeostasis, and a must read.
Anyway, these days my fasting blood glucose readings have been regularly in the 100 to 125 range. Obviously, while I have been talking the talk, I have not always been walking the walk. I admit it. I “cheat” a little almost every day;always just before or at any time after dinner. And I pay the price. It’s just a little “cheat,” so I don’t gain weight, but neither do I lose any weight EVEN THOUGH I AM EATING NO MORE THAN +/- 1500-1800 CALORIES ON MOST CHEAT DAYS.
What’s happening, I hypothesize, is that my serum insulin levels are slightly elevated – elevated just enough to turn everything I (ch)eat to fat and stop the breakdown of body fat in storage. My body’s autonomically functioning metabolism, the milieu intérieur, “gets the message” that as long as I have a supply of quick energy every night (the “cheats” that break down to carbs), it can conserve my body fat, and lay on more with every calorie that isn’t needed to maintain my basal metabolism while I sleep. The “signal” is: my slightly elevated serum insulin circulating my slightly elevated glucose. If this is still a little unclear to you, dear reader, read Taubes’s “10 Certain Conclusions” (linked above) through a few times.

Wednesday, May 21, 2014

The Nutrition Debate #211: Eggs and Satiety

Kris Gunnars at Authority Nutrition recently posted this PubMed link to a 2005 abstract from the Journal of the American College of Nutrition (J Am Coll Nutr). It is titled, “Short-term effect of eggs on satiety in overweight and obese subjects.” Curiously, there were no comments on this article in Pub Med, an official governmental organ of ncbi/nlm/nih. Maybe, in 2005, eating eggs, due to their saturated fat and cholesterol, was still a no-no, and no one in the “scientific/medical” community could figure out how to support the idea that whole eggs (yolks included) could be part of a “healthy eating” pattern. Fortunately, that perception has since changed. Whole eggs are one of the healthiest foods on earth.
The OBJECTIVE of this small prospective, randomized, crossover-design study was clearly stated: “To test the hypotheses that among overweight and obese participants, a breakfast consisting of eggs, in comparison to an isocaloric equal-weight bagel-based breakfast, would induce greater satiety, reduce perceived cravings, and reduce subsequent short-term energy intake.” Thirty women with BMIs of at least 25 between the ages of 25 and 60 years were recruited to participate.
The RESULTS were clear: “During the pre-lunch period, participants had greater feelings of satiety after the egg breakfast, and consumed significantly less energy.” In addition, “Energy intake following the egg breakfast remained lower for the entire day… as well as for the next 36 hours.”
“CONCLUSIONS: Compared to an isocaloric, equal weight bagel-based breakfast, the egg-breakfast induced greater satiety and significantly reduced short-term food intake. The potential role of a routine egg breakfast in producing a sustained caloric deficit and consequent weight loss should be determined.” In other words, they want the NIH to fund more studies like this!!! Government funded research, remember, is a jobs program, but in this case, one that should be supported (LOL).
Personally, as my readers know, I ate a breakfast of 2 eggs and 2 strips of bacon (plus coffee with H&H and sweetener) for almost 10 years. Then, a couple of years ago, after reading Paul and Shou-Ching Jaminet’s Perfect Health Diet (pg. 321), I switched to 3 eggs and 1 strip of bacon (plus coffee) to get my daily dose of choline all in one meal. And I have been telling people for years that, when you eat this breakfast, and this breakfast alone (with no fruit or juice or bread products), you will not be hungry – not in mid-morning, not at lunch, not even at mid-afternoon. I haven’t been hungry at lunch for years.
You may ask, then, “Why do you eat lunch?” That’s a good question. Increasingly I have been asking myself that question too. I even drafted a column a few years ago, “Two meals or three meals a day?” but never published it. The reason, I suspect, is that, again as my readers know, I eat a can of sardines in olive oil for lunch (when I remember to eat lunch). And my editor thinks that the almost daily dose of sardines and olive oil is one of the reasons I have very high HDLs (~90mg/dL) and very low triglycerides (~34mg/dL). I am reluctant to give up such stellar lipids. For the record, my most recent Total Cholesterol was 207 and my LDL 110. But it wasn’t always this way. To see how my HDL and triglycerides changed after I started eating Very Low Carb, see The Nutrition Debate #67 (HDL) here and The Nutrition Debate #68 (triglycerides) here.
Another bit of self-promotion: Take a look at The Nutrition Debate #91, “Low Carb Breakfasts (and a no-carb lunch)” for more ideas on eggs and breakfast and The Nutrition Debate #176, “Eggs, Cholesterol and Choline,” for more information.
So, in conclusion, there’s no question (in my mind) of the “short-term effect of eggs on satiety in overweight and obese subjects,” like me. It also “reduce(d) perceived [“perceived”?!!] cravings, and reduce(d) subsequent short-term energy intake,” including the viable election not to eat lunch at all! I wouldn’t miss it, seriously. If fact, on many days it’s only the clock, not my stomach, that tells me I missed lunch. I also agree completely that “the potential role of a routine egg breakfast in producing a sustained caloric deficit and consequent weight loss should be determined.” Why don’t you try it?
N.B. The eggs I buy are raised by a local farmer who also raises beef and pigs and sells them all at our local farmers’ market. They use a hen mobile (a chicken coop on wheels) that they move from pasture to pasture week by week after the livestock have been themselves moved on to new grazing. Hens are omnivores (like pigs) and so they (and we) benefit from the insects and larvae that they find in the deposits the animals leave behind. This is all explained in The Omnivore’s Dilemma, a book by Michael Pollan in which he canonizes the practices of JoelSalatin of Polyface Farm in Virginia’s Shenandoah Valley.
Trivia: Did you know that Abraham Lincoln’s usual breakfast was a 1 poached egg and coffee. No wonder he was so skinny.
PS: “Too busy to eat breakfast”? Pack one or two hard boiled eggs to eat at your desk. If that’s not enough, add a slice of smoked salmon wrapped around some full-fat cream cheese. There’s a hardy, healthy, very low carb “breakfast on the run.”

The Nutrition Debate #211: Eggs and Satiety

Kris Gunnars at Authority Nutrition recently posted this PubMed link to a 2005 abstract from the Journal of the American College of Nutrition (J Am Coll Nutr). It is titled, “Short-term effect of eggs on satiety in overweight and obese subjects.” Curiously, there were no comments on this article in Pub Med, an official governmental organ of ncbi/nlm/nih. Maybe, in 2005, eating eggs, due to their saturated fat and cholesterol, was still a no-no, and no one in the “scientific/medical” community could figure out how to support the idea that whole eggs (yolks included) could be part of a “healthy eating” pattern. Fortunately, that perception has since changed. Whole eggs are one of the healthiest foods on earth.
The OBJECTIVE of this small prospective, randomized, crossover-design study was clearly stated: “To test the hypotheses that among overweight and obese participants, a breakfast consisting of eggs, in comparison to an isocaloric equal-weight bagel-based breakfast, would induce greater satiety, reduce perceived cravings, and reduce subsequent short-term energy intake.” Thirty women with BMIs of at least 25 between the ages of 25 and 60 years were recruited to participate.
The RESULTS were clear: “During the pre-lunch period, participants had greater feelings of satiety after the egg breakfast, and consumed significantly less energy.” In addition, “Energy intake following the egg breakfast remained lower for the entire day… as well as for the next 36 hours.”
“CONCLUSIONS: Compared to an isocaloric, equal weight bagel-based breakfast, the egg-breakfast induced greater satiety and significantly reduced short-term food intake. The potential role of a routine egg breakfast in producing a sustained caloric deficit and consequent weight loss should be determined.” In other words, they want the NIH to fund more studies like this!!! Government funded research, remember, is a jobs program, but in this case, one that should be supported (LOL).
Personally, as my readers know, I ate a breakfast of 2 eggs and 2 strips of bacon (plus coffee with H&H and sweetener) for almost 10 years. Then, a couple of years ago, after reading Paul and Shou-Ching Jaminet’s Perfect Health Diet (pg. 321), I switched to 3 eggs and 1 strip of bacon (plus coffee) to get my daily dose of choline all in one meal. And I have been telling people for years that, when you eat this breakfast, and this breakfast alone (with no fruit or juice or bread products), you will not be hungry – not in mid-morning, not at lunch, not even at mid-afternoon. I haven’t been hungry at lunch for years.
You may ask, then, “Why do you eat lunch?” That’s a good question. Increasingly I have been asking myself that question too. I even drafted a column a few years ago, “Two meals or three meals a day?” but never published it. The reason, I suspect, is that, again as my readers know, I eat a can of sardines in olive oil for lunch (when I remember to eat lunch). And my editor thinks that the almost daily dose of sardines and olive oil is one of the reasons I have very high HDLs (~90mg/dL) and very low triglycerides (~34mg/dL). I am reluctant to give up such stellar lipids. For the record, my most recent Total Cholesterol was 207 and my LDL 110. But it wasn’t always this way. To see how my HDL and triglycerides changed after I started eating Very Low Carb, see The Nutrition Debate #67 (HDL) here and The Nutrition Debate #68 (triglycerides) here.
Another bit of self-promotion: Take a look at The Nutrition Debate #91, “Low Carb Breakfasts (and a no-carb lunch)” for more ideas on eggs and breakfast and The Nutrition Debate #176, “Eggs, Cholesterol and Choline,” for more information.
So, in conclusion, there’s no question (in my mind) of the “short-term effect of eggs on satiety in overweight and obese subjects,” like me. It also “reduce(d) perceived [“perceived”?!!] cravings, and reduce(d) subsequent short-term energy intake,” including the viable election not to eat lunch at all! I wouldn’t miss it, seriously. If fact, on many days it’s only the clock, not my stomach, that tells me I missed lunch. I also agree completely that “the potential role of a routine egg breakfast in producing a sustained caloric deficit and consequent weight loss should be determined.” Why don’t you try it?
N.B. The eggs I buy are raised by a local farmer who also raises beef and pigs and sells them all at our local farmers’ market. They use a hen mobile (a chicken coop on wheels) that they move from pasture to pasture week by week after the livestock have been themselves moved on to new grazing. Hens are omnivores (like pigs) and so they (and we) benefit from the insects and larvae that they find in the deposits the animals leave behind. This is all explained in The Omnivore’s Dilemma, a book by Michael Pollan in which he canonizes the practices of JoelSalatin of Polyface Farm in Virginia’s Shenandoah Valley.
Trivia: Did you know that Abraham Lincoln’s usual breakfast was a 1 poached egg and coffee. No wonder he was so skinny.
PS: “Too busy to eat breakfast”? Pack one or two hard boiled eggs to eat at your desk. If that’s not enough, add a slice of smoked salmon wrapped around some full-fat cream cheese. There’s a hardy, healthy, very low carb “breakfast on the run.”